A parody is generally permissible if it evokes the well-known original work while being clearly different from it. In addition, it must contain an element of humour or mockery. The court accepted that Dikke Pens met these requirements. However, that was not the end of the matter. A fair balance still had to be struck between ABBA’s copyright interests and the band’s freedom of expression. That is where the parody defence ultimately failed.
The melody of the ABBA song could be heard throughout the entire work. Moreover, the band had a clear commercial interest. By distributing the song through Spotify, it was able to reach a large audience, generate streaming income and increase performance bookings. Unlike a temporary or limited parody, a song uploaded to Spotify is available continuously and worldwide. The lyrics also focused on obesity rather than romance, creating an association that ABBA considered undesirable. In those circumstances, the band’s appeal to freedom of expression did not succeed.
The band may continue to perform the song live at events, but commercial exploitation through Spotify is not permitted.